On Friday Brooklynne & I went to see “Under the Same Moon (La Misma Luna)” in Little Rock. We’ll start with a brief synopsis.
“Under the Same Moon” follows the parallel journeys of Rosario & her son, Carlitos.
Rosario’s Journey
Rosario is an illegal immigrant to the US. Rosario left her son, Carlitos, with her mother in Mexico when he was 5 years old & has come to America in hopes of becoming a legal citizen in order to provide a better life for her son. They write letters to one another & she calls him from a pay phone every Sunday at 10 a.m. sharp. Rosario is working hard to earn enough money for a lawyer that will help her attain US citizenship. She is working 2 housekeeping jobs while making & selling dresses in her free time in order to earn enough money. However, providing for her mother & son back in Mexico & the cost of living, even poorly, for herself in LA, make saving money for lawyer fees almost impossible. Rosario realizes that the very thing she came to America for (her son) is the one who is now suffering because she left Mexico. As Rosario comes to this realization another legal solution presents itself, & she begins to struggle with whether to go back to Mexico or to take this new & easy, although legal, way out.
Carlitos’ Journey
Carlitos is a 9 year old boy living with his grandmother in Mexico. The highlight of his life is every Sunday at 10 a.m. sharp when he goes to the pay phone in town for his weekly call from his mom whom he has not seen in 4 years. Every morning Carlitos wakes early to make breakfast for his grandmother & to remind her to take her medicine before heading off to school. When he wakes one morning to find that his grandmother has passed away during the night, he decides that he must find his way across the border to get to his mother. He has no way of getting in touch with his mother in LA, & he doesn’t want her to worry about him. So, he decides that he’d better hurry up because he has only 6 days to make it to his mother in LA before she calls for him at 10 a.m. sharp on Sunday morning & he is not there to answer the phone for the first time in 4 years.
I really enjoyed this movie for 3 reasons. First of all, its just a good story, & the director, Patricia Riggen, did an excellent job of giving the story center stage. Obviously, this movie involves a very politically charged topic in illegal immigration. Riggen could have easily sacrificed some of the story depth for the sake of “making a point” for a political cause. Don’t get the wrong idea here, there are plenty of tongue-in-cheek references to the immigration issue (my personal favorite was the use of the song “Superman Es Illegal (Superman Is An Illegal)” during a short scene featuring migrant workers), & it is not unclear where the makers of the movie stand on the issue. What I am saying is that the movie doesn’t come off as forcing a political agenda.
Second of all, it was very well acted by the 2 main characters. Carlitos is played so adorably by Adrian Alonso that it is almost impossible not to love this child. He is a kind & generous boy who loves & enjoys life even in a situation that is less than desirable. It may not necessarily be good “acting” because he’s just a cute looking kid anyway, but who am I to say he’s not a brat & a holy terror in real life. I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt & say he’s a good actor. Rosario is played superbly by Kate del Castillo. She does an excellent job of personifying the tension of her situation & she makes it easy for the audience to sympathize with her.
Finally, I liked the movie because I left feeling gently rebuked. While I didn’t feel guilty for supporting immigration reform after this movie, I did feel guilty for devaluing & dehumanizing people by being insensitive towards others. Its not like I’ve been a hateful bigot or anything, but I have been guilty of talking privately about & thinking about Latino immigrants as if they were merely robots that spoke spanish. I liked that the movie gave an example of a possible sympathetic immigrant situation without an “in your face” attitude trying to make you believe that every immigrant is just thinking of their poor children & pursuing the American dream through legal & pure hearted ways. I was reminded, in a positive way, of what I’ve always known, but have often denied with my words & thoughts. Who anyone is is the result of a mixture of events both fortunate & unfortunate, choices both good & bad, consequences both positive & negative, & circumstances sometimes self-inflicted & sometimes unfair that have brought them to this moment in time. So, in order to make an accurate judgment about the value of another person I must possess 2 pieces of information.
1) An exhaustive & accurate knowledge of the events, choices, consequences, & circumstances of that person’s entire life.
2) An accurate, absolute perception & understanding of right & wrong in any & every scenario that person was faced with.
If I don’t have both pieces, it is my belief that I should offer love, compassion, & grace to that person. So, I have made 4 lists to keep handy at all times.
People Who Meet Criteria #1
1) Me
People Who Meet Criteria #2
No one
People About Whom I Can Make Accurate Value Judgments
No one
People I Should Offer Love, Compassion, & Grace To
1) Everyone
2) Their Mom
I will leave you with the words of the always amazing Derek Webb
“There’s no categories, just long stories waiting to be heard.”